Switching brokers · California

The broker of record letter: how it actually works.

If you have decided to change insurance brokers, the mechanism that gets you there is a one-page document: the broker of record letter. It is not a cancellation request, and it does not itself request a coverage or premium change. It asks your carrier to recognize a new broker on the account, subject to the carrier’s acceptance and the broker’s eligibility or appointment. Here is what it typically says, how carriers process it, and the timing that determines whether it helps you or just moves the same problem to a new desk.

At a glance

One letterstarts the request; the carrier’s written acceptance completes it

What changesWho services the account
Not requestedA carrier, coverage or premium change
Named brokerEmmi Ensign, on every policy

The mechanics

What a BOR letter is, and is not.

A broker of record letter is a short letter from you, the named insured, to your carrier, appointing a new broker on a policy you already hold. That is the entire function. It is not a cancellation notice. It does not itself request a new policy, a coverage change or a premium change. Whether the carrier accepts it depends on the carrier’s procedures, including whether the new broker is eligible or appointed with that carrier, and the change takes effect on the date the carrier confirms for each policy. Once accepted, the carrier lists the new broker of record, which determines who services the policy day to day. Commission follows the carrier’s rules: State Fund, for example, keeps midyear commissions with the original broker of record, and the new broker becomes commissionable at renewal.

That distinction matters because a lot of business owners hear “change brokers” and assume it means re-underwriting their whole insurance program from scratch. A BOR letter used mid-term does not itself request that. Re-underwriting happens when you remarket a policy, which is a separate move usually timed to renewal. A BOR letter is narrower: it asks to move service on a policy that already exists, without itself requesting new terms.

Per carrierfollow each carrier’s current required form and submission instructionsNOT A CANCELLATION
Service onlythe letter itself does not request a carrier, coverage or premium changeNO CHANGE REQUESTED
Variescarrier acceptance, waiting or rescission period and effective date, set by each carrierVARIES BY CARRIER

Copy and adapt

The letter itself.

The letter is short on purpose. Carriers look for specific facts, which vary by carrier: who you are, which policy or policies you mean, and who you are appointing. Anything longer tends to slow the review down rather than speed it up. Here is an illustrative structure, not any carrier’s required form.

[Company Letterhead]
[Date]

[Carrier Name]
[Carrier Address]

RE: Named Insured: [Your Company Name]
Policy Number(s): [Policy Number(s)]
Policy Period: [Effective Date] to [Expiration Date]

Effective [date], we hereby appoint [New Brokerage Name], [License #], as our exclusive broker of record for the policies referenced above, replacing any broker previously designated. This appointment does not authorize the cancellation, rewriting, or remarketing of the referenced policies without our written consent. Please direct all correspondence regarding these policies to [New Brokerage Name].

[Signature]
[Name]
[Title]

Treat this as an illustration. Obtain the carrier’s current required form, signatory authority, account/policy details and submission instructions. Confirm acceptance in writing. Requirements differ: State Fund, for example, asks for the policyholder’s letterhead, its State Fund access number, a producer contact and active brokerage email, and a currently dated signature from someone whose authority appears in its policy records. Policies with different carriers need a separate request to each carrier.

Notice the sentence that limits authorization: it appoints a new broker, and it explicitly withholds authority to cancel, rewrite, or remarket without your written consent. That line is there to protect you. It keeps the letter from being read as a blank check to make changes to your program. A broker asking you to sign something broader than this is asking for more authority than a BOR transfer requires.

Step by step

How the process actually runs.

  1. Choose the new broker and agree the 90-day plan

    Before any letter goes out, settle what happens after service transfers, specifically what gets reviewed and when the account gets marketed at renewal.

  2. Prepare each carrier’s request

    Use each carrier’s current required form, signatory rules and submission instructions. Different carriers each need their own request.

  3. The carrier reviews the request

    The carrier checks the letter and the new broker’s eligibility or appointment, and may hold the request open for a waiting or rescission period first. State Fund, for example, notifies the incumbent broker and determines the broker of record five business days later; other carriers set their own procedures.

  4. Expect the incumbent’s call

    Once the current broker is notified, they will typically reach out. Keep the conversation short and firm: you have made a decision, thank them for their service, and let the new broker of record handle it from here.

  5. Confirm acceptance, then plan the renewal

    Service moves once the carrier accepts the appointment, on the effective date it sets. Confirm acceptance in writing; the new broker then becomes the point of contact and starts working the renewal timeline.

Watch out

A BOR letter moves service, not price. If your premium is the actual complaint, pair the letter with a renewal marketing plan, because the letter alone does not shop your program to other carriers. And if a broker is pushing you to sign a BOR letter on the spot, slow down and ask them what their 90-day plan is first. Signing hands them your account with no built-in obligation to remarket it.

California timing

As a planning proposal, we suggest executing the letter 90 to 120 days before renewal so a new broker has time to market your program. For the commercial policies it covers, Insurance Code 678.1 requires non-renewal notice 60 to 120 days before the policy ends; that notice window is not the outer limit for shopping, and starting earlier gives the incoming broker more runway than scrambling near expiration.

Two different problems

BOR now, or remarket at renewal?

These solve two different problems, and it helps to be clear on which one you actually have. A BOR letter asks the carrier to change who services your existing policy, mid-term, without itself requesting other changes. Remarketing shops your program to other carriers at renewal, looking for a better price or a better structure. If your broker has gone quiet and you just want a name who answers the phone, that’s a BOR problem. If your rates keep climbing and you want to know what else is out there, that’s a remarketing problem, though if your broker has gone quiet it’s often both at once.

PathWhat changesWhen it fitsWatch out for
Broker of record letterService and point of contact, mid-term, once the carrier acceptsYou need responsiveness now and don’t want to wait for renewalThe letter does not request a coverage or premium change; audits, policy adjustments, fees and renewal terms may still affect what you pay
Remarket at renewalCarrier, price, and structureYou have time before expiration and want the program tested against the marketWe suggest starting 90 to 120 days before renewal; available time, insurer response and account complexity vary, especially if you are holding a non-renewal notice

Often the right sequence is both, in that order: sign the BOR letter now to get a named, responsive broker in place, then let that broker market the renewal with as much lead time as you can give it.

Common questions

BOR letters, answered.

The mechanics raise a handful of the same questions every time. Here are the ones we hear most from California owners and CFOs sizing up the move.

Request a program review

Get a quote

Written and kept current by the Golden Benchmark team. Your named broker is Emmi Ensign, a licensed California broker at Golden Benchmark Insurance Services (agency CA License 0D06566), which has placed commercial insurance for California businesses since 1988.

Does a BOR letter cancel or change my policy?

No. A BOR request is different from a cancellation request. The letter itself does not request a change to the carrier, policy number, coverage terms or premium. If the carrier accepts it, it changes who services the account and who the carrier corresponds with, from the effective date the carrier confirms.

Will my premium change?

The letter itself does not request a coverage or premium change; separate audits, policy adjustments, fees and renewal terms may still affect what you pay.

Can I undo a BOR letter?

It may be possible within the carrier’s waiting or rescission period, if it has one; procedures vary by carrier. The appointment takes effect only once the carrier accepts it, so confirm acceptance and the effective date in writing.

Will my current broker know, and what will they do?

Usually. Carriers commonly notify the incumbent broker as part of processing the letter, and the incumbent may call you directly once they hear. Decide ahead of time what you’ll say. A short, firm answer, thanking them and confirming the decision is made, is usually all that’s needed.

Should I sign a BOR or wait for renewal?

If the problem is service, responsiveness, or simply having a named person who answers, changing the servicing broker may address a service problem; agree on responsibilities and response expectations first. If the problem is price or program structure, that’s a renewal marketing question, and we suggest starting 90 to 120 days out so a new broker has more time to shop it.

Ready to be looked after properly?

Bring us the policies. We’ll map the next steps.

Bring us your current policies and a named California broker maps the program, the timing, and the letters themselves, no call center, no rotating desk. If a BOR letter is the right first move, we’ll tell you that too.

CA License #0D06566 · Named broker on every policy